Friday, September 19, 2014

rough draft for Thompson essay (part 3)

Analytical Response to Thompson’s “Public Thinking”
            Clive Thompson, author of “Public Thinking” has been a long time writer for the New York Times newspaper, and rightfully so. His diction exemplifies tremendous passion in his writing. One of his most famous works in which he demonstrates this is “Public Thinking”. Interestingly enough, in his earlier years, Thompson viewed the Internet and social media as an increasing downfall of society. To his surprise, he began to see only good coming from this launch into a new technological era. People were writing in large amounts like no one has ever seen before, not to mention the quality of writing due to “the audience effect” had also taken a turn for the best. These are just two of the positive attributes Thompson sees in online writing. His purpose for writing this essay is to demonstrate to the public a number of ways that writing online is actually increasing our literacy. He expresses himself so deeply, due to the fact that this topic is very controversial and people usually tend to lean more toward technology and online writing becoming a detrimental thing to our society. Thompson uses a number of evidence to inform the reader every reason as to why this is a common misconception. In my analytical response to Thompson’s text, I will examine the different techniques he uses in his evidence to show just how effectively he explains and executes every piece of evidence he provides the reader.
Although Americans today tend to believe that the increasing use of the internet and other forms of technology has a negative effect on society as a whole, there are 3 main forms of evidence that are properly executed in order to support Thompson’s case that Americans are in fact, wrong. An experimental study done by professor Brenna Clarke Gray illustrates the audience affect on her students by assigning them to create a Wikipedia entry on Canadian writers. After her study, Gray shared that her students did significantly better on this assignment than the others, primarily due to the fact that they took it more seriously. She states, “It was like night and day” (56).  She uses night and day as opposites in order to show her pathos to her study and to instill within the reader just how successful and persuasive this study was. The fact that the idea of online prose is such an abundant way of writing to one’s highest potential as to use it in an academic study goes to show that this discovery is far from myth. However, to every study is a little error. In the case of this example, it would have benefitted the reader vastly if this analysis were to have been replicated on individuals in the middle school age to see if maturity has a factor on the results.  
            In addition to this study, Thompson uses an incidence in history to support the idea that the way we think is a product of our environment. “If four astronomers discovered sunspots at the same time, it’s partly because of the quality of lenses in telescopes in 1611 had matured to the point where it was finally possible to pick out small details on the sun and partly because the question of the sun’s role in the universe had become newly interesting in the wake of Copernicus’s heliocentric theory” (Thompson 59). This directly ties into present-day Americans and the development of the Internet as a place where we can freely express ourselves through our individual and original writing. If the people who surround us are writing more due to the accessibility and convenience of the Internet, we will follow the crowd due to our human nature of being “pack animals”. The increase in popularity also leads to more competition such as: “Who always has a really well-written Facebook status” or even, “Who has the cleverest captions to their pictures on Instagram?” These rhetorical questions are just two examples in which Americans have found themselves to ask while surfing through social media sites and directly correlates to the increase in human cognition. This is evident in human nature to always be “on top” or have a competitive “alpha” mentality. This claim of Thompson’s is quite effective as he brings a new element into his evidence by adding an example from history. He proves that this is the way human behavior has worked for centuries and there is no reason why now is the time when that comes to an end.
            One of Thompson’s concluding points includes a personal anecdote on Ernest Duchesne and his original discovery of penicillin. Due to the fact that Duchesne was young and not very well known, his writings of the discovery weren’t noticed. It took 47 years, and millions of people dead from diseases, for its rediscovery by Scottish scientist Alexander Fleming to finally be accepted by the public. “Failed networks kill ideas” (Thompson 61). This was the perfect thing for Thompson to say in his work because it truly adds another element of pathos. Pathos is an important component in successful writing today because the reader is given the opportunity to understand in more of a personal manner. This writing technique is becoming more popular because Americans are starting to realize what grabs the reader’s attention and allows for the author to be easily noticed. If Duchesne and Fleming were to have the same connections we do today, millions of innocent lives could have been saved.
To wrap it all up, it is clear that Thompson was able to connect to the reader through his various writing styles and types of evidence. I have portrayed in this paper, his exemplary use of just 3 of his main claims: an account in history, experimental study, and lastly a personal anecdote. His argument is very relevant which is another main reason why so many people are interested in what he has to say. It has been a common misconception in the past that technology was actually the antagonist of developing society and used as a crutch for people’s lazy writing. But through his writing, people began to listen, for what he had to say instilled a new thought in the minds of people whom technology greatly affects. The Internet “encourages public thinking and resolves multiples on a much larger scale and at a pace more dementedly rapid” (Thompson 61).



Tuesday, September 9, 2014

rough draft for Thompson essay (part 2)

Natalie Goetz
Professor Werry
RWS 100
09 September 2014
Analytical Response to Thompson’s “Public Thinking”
            Clive Thompson, author of “Public Thinking” has been a long time writer for the New York Times newspaper, and rightfully so. His diction exemplifies tremendous passion in his writing. One of his most famous works in which he demonstrates this is “Public Thinking”. Interestingly enough, in his earlier years, Thompson viewed the Internet and social media as an increasing downfall of society. To his surprise, he began to see only good coming from this launch into a new technological era. People were writing in large amounts like no one has ever seen before, not to mention the quality of writing due to “the audience effect” had also taken a turn for the best. These are just two of the positive attributes Thompson sees in online writing. His purpose for writing this essay is to demonstrate to the public a number of ways that writing online is actually increasing our literacy. He expresses himself so deeply, due to the fact that this topic is very controversial and people usually tend to lean more toward technology and online writing becoming a detrimental thing to our society. Thompson uses a number of evidence to inform the reader every reason as to why this is a common misconception. In my analytical response to Thompson’s text, I will examine the different techniques he uses in his evidence to show just how effectively he explains and executes every piece of evidence he provides the reader.
Although Americans today tend to believe that the increasing use of the internet and other forms of technology has a negative effect on society as a whole, there are 3 main forms of evidence that are properly executed in order to support Thompson’s case that Americans are in fact, wrong. An experimental study done by professor Brenna Clarke Gray illustrates the audience affect on her students by assigning them to create a Wikipedia entry on Canadian writers. After her study, Gray shared that her students did significantly better on this assignment than the others, primarily due to the fact that they took it more seriously. She states, “It was like night and day” (56).  She uses night and day as opposites in order to show her pathos to her study and to instill within the reader just how successful and persuasive this study was. The fact that the idea of online prose is such an abundant way of writing to one’s highest potential as to use it in an academic study goes to show that this discovery is far from myth. However, to every study is a little error. In the case of this example, it would have benefitted the reader vastly if this analysis were to have been replicated on individuals in the middle school age to see if maturity has a factor on the results.  


Monday, September 8, 2014

rough draft for Thompson essay (part 1)

Analytical Response to Thompson’s “Public Thinking”
            Clive Thompson, author of “Public Thinking” has been a long time writer for the New York Times newspaper, and rightfully so. His diction exemplifies tremendous passion in his writing. One of his most famous works in which he demonstrates this is “Public Thinking”. Interestingly enough, in his earlier years, Thompson viewed the Internet and social media as an increasing downfall of society. To his surprise, he began to see only good coming from this launch into a new technological era. People were writing in large amounts like no one has ever seen before, not to mention the quality of writing due to “the audience effect” had also taken a turn for the best. These are just two of the positive attributes Thompson sees in online writing. His purpose for writing this essay is to demonstrate to the public a number of ways that writing online is actually increasing our literacy. He expresses himself so deeply, due to the fact that this topic is very controversial and people usually tend to lean more toward the use of technology and online writing being a detrimental thing to our society. Thompson uses a number of evidence to inform the reader every reason as to why this is a common misconception. In my analytical response to Thompson’s text, I will examine the different techniques he uses in his evidence to show just how effectively he explains and executes every piece of evidence he provides the reader.
Although abundant in Thompson’s reasons for his belief that America is increasingly becoming more literate, there are 3 main forms of evidence that are properly executed in order to support his case. An experimental study done by professor Brenna Clarke Gray illustrates the audience affect on her students by assigning them to create a Wikipedia entry on Canadian writers. After her study, Gray shared that her students did significantly better on this assignment than the others, primarily because they took it more seriously. She states, “It was like night and day” (56).  She uses night and day as opposites in an attempt to try and show her pathos to this study she conducted to instill within the reader just how successful and persuasive her study was. The fact that the idea of online prose is such an abundant way of writing to one’s highest potential as to use it in an academic study goes to show that this discovery is far from myth. However, to every study is a little error. And in the case of this example, it would have benefitted the reader vastly if this study were to have been replicated to individuals in the middle school age to see if age has a factor on the results.  


Thursday, September 4, 2014

Analyzing Thompson (part 2)

            There are many elements to Thompson’s work “Public Thinking” that seem ambiguous to me as a reader. If I were to ask Thompson any 2 questions regarding his text, one would be: “Do you have any opinions toward the increased use of technology being a negative thing?” I feel if Thompson were to answer this, he may be a little more credible in my eyes because he has the ability to see both sides of the equation.  Furthermore, it would be interesting to know the background of Thompson’s childhood that may have perhaps had an impact on his opinion.
            I definitely agree with all of the points that Thompson makes, which is why I think he was very successful in persuading the reader to more easily concur with him. The addition of entailing personal statistics as to how much an average person writes now versus what they did in the past. Also helped his argument. However, I think the anecdote of the Kenyan woman wasn’t as effective as Thompson would have liked it to be. It felt a little out of place with the rest of his evidence. Secondly, I think he should have given the reader a piece of evidence that pertains to him and his personal life experiences. It seemed like he just gathered this wide array of evidence and mushed it all together to try and prove his point; there was no real personal flair he put into his piece to make the reader feel like this wasn’t just a typical research paper with a ton of random facts.

            Although I don’t agree with Thompson’s initial piece of evidence regarding the Kenyan blogger, it didn’t just randomly find its way onto his essay.  He wanted to give a personal account of someone who had doors open up to them through their writing. How the idea of social networking is a powerful idea and if used correctly, can be used to you’re advantage as it did Ory Okolloh. He connects this story to his essay as a whole by encouraging people who wish to be publically noticed to seriously consider the internet being that social media a huge part in today’s society.

Wednesday, September 3, 2014

Response to "Public Thinking" by Clive Thompson

Natalie Goetz
Professor Werry
RWS 100
3 September 2014
Response to “Public Thinking”
In most rhetoric texts, there is a main point the author tries to convey embedded in a variety of different forms of evidence and filler words used to guide the reader into taking the side of the writer, “Public Thinking” by Clive Thompson being a prime example. In his essay, he seeks an answer to the larger question: Is the invention of new technologies and other advancements hindering the American ability to write and analyze, or is it encouraging them to express their views and become more educated through works of others as well as their own? Thompson’s objective for his essay is to lead us towards a clear understanding of whether or not human advancements are key to increasing global awareness, communication and literacy focused on writing. Nevertheless, it becomes apparent through his copious amounts of evidence that he believes America is creating more opportunities to become literate through writing. Whether its through college research papers, blogs, or Facebook, Americans have obviously increased the amount they individually express themselves through writing. This is clear through Weinberg’s personal realization of an interesting element in “Moneyball”. “Weinberg’s process of crafting his idea—and trying to make it clever for his readers—had uncovered its true dimensions” (Thompson 54). This goes to show, that by nature, human understanding essentially lays in the composition of an idea through the eyes of the audience. However, this is just one form of evidence he uses to help the reader better understand his valid stance.
Although abundant in Thompson’s reasons for his belief that America is increasingly becoming more literate, there are 3 main forms of evidence that are properly executed in order to support his case. An experimental study done by professor Brenna Clarke Gray illustrates the audience affect on her students by assigning them to create a Wikipedia entry on Canadian writers. After her study, Gray shared that her students did significantly better on this assignment than the others primarily because they took it more seriously. She states, “It was like night and day” (56). 
In addition to this study, Thompson uses an incidence in history to support the idea that the way we think is a product of our environment. “If four astronomers discovered sunspots at the same time, it’s partly because of the quality of lenses in telescopes in 1611had matured to the point where it was finally possible to pick out small details on the sun and partly because the question of the sun’s role in the universe had become newly interesting in the wake of Copernicus’s heliocentric theory” (Thompson 59). This directly ties into present-day Americans and the development of the Internet as a place where they can freely express themselves through their individual and original writing.
One of Thompson’s concluding points includes a personal anecdote on Ernest Duchesne and his original discovery of penicillin. Due to the fact that Duchesne was young and not very well known, his writings of the discovery weren’t noticed. It took 47 years, and millions of people dead from diseases, for its rediscovery by Scottish scientist Alexander Fleming to finally be accepted by the public. “Failed networks kill ideas” (Thompson 61).  If Duchesne and Fleming were to have the same connections we do today, millions of innocent lives could have been saved. The Internet “encourages public thinking and resolves multiples on a much larger scale and at a pace more dementedly rapid” (Thompson 61).